James Chappell's Rating & Review:

I am happy to say that despite its shortcomings AOTC is still a very enjoyable experience. Even if it has a mechanical, pre-determined feel we know that thesping is not what Star Wars is about. It is about excitement, wonder, and the child inside us. If only the child inside some of us stopped taking it so personally when somebody slates a Star Wars movie. Let others dislike what they will. Let it be their problem that they don't like Star Wars. Maybe then some of us willgrow up...Full review

Marcus Chan's Rating & Review:

To those who love Star Wars only for its effects, this film is worth ten times the price of their tickets, but for those who look for things beyond nostalgia and eye candy, they will be gravely disappointed by the many things this film has promised but failed to deliver - the romance, the energy, the creativity. If your mind is clear enough, it will strike you that like "The Phantom Menace", "Attack of the Clones" merely employs the assets built by the first three films, without contributing anything back...Full review

Adam Sayovitz's Rating & Review:

I enjoyed this recent episode of Star Wars more than I could've ever imagined. I found AOTC to have striking similarities with the old trilogy. An intoxicating romantic subplot, one that hasn't been seen since "The Empire Strikes Back". The relationship that Anakin and Padme share had me constantly torn between the decisions they make about being romantically involved...Full review